When State Law Defies Federal Authority: Maine’s Title IX Policy Sparks Constitutional Clash
A legal and cultural flashpoint is unfolding in Maine, and it could have sweeping implications for civil rights law across the country.
In a recent televised segment on WMTW Channel 8, Keith Altman, nationally recognized Title IX and student rights attorney, analyzed Maine’s controversial refusal to comply with the Trump administration’s Title IX guidance requiring schools to not allow transgender girls to compete in girls’ sports. At the heart of the debate? The Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
“If a state’s law conflicts with federal law, the federal law prevails. That’s the foundation of our legal system,” Altman explained. “Maine is positioning itself in direct conflict with the federal government, which is a dangerous legal strategy.”
The Legal Issue: Supremacy Clause in Action
The Supremacy Clause (Article VI of the U.S. Constitution) ensures that federal law takes precedence over any conflicting state statutes. That’s the cornerstone of Altman’s analysis – and it’s likely to be central in any future litigation.
“If Maine continues to defy the Trump administration’s latest guidance and the federal government chooses to act—either through legal enforcement or by withholding federal funding – the courts will ultimately need to decide,” said Altman.
Why This Matters to Schools and Students
For school administrators, parents, and students – especially those navigating gender identity issues – this legal standoff creates uncertainty. Will students be caught in the middle of a political battle? This situation underscores the importance of having legal advocates who understand the intersection of education policy, civil rights, and constitutional law.
Our Role at K Altman Law
At K Altman Law, we don’t take a political side. Our focus is on ensuring that students and educators understand their rights and are equipped to advocate in legally complex situations like this. Whether we’re representing a student or advising a school on compliance protocols, our commitment is to the law and educational fairness.
Watch the Channel 8 segment featuring Keith Altman
Read more about our work in Title IX and Student Defense
